Kyle is the focus of the sketch "Totally Kyle", a stereotypical, dim-witted hippie surfer with a thick Californian accent. In the sketch he tells about mundane, everyday happenings in his life, which almost always start with the line "One time...".

He is played by Drake Bell. The character has long, messy, shaggy blonde hair and a baggy, tie-dye shirt. He used the word "like" a lot, and always had a pale yellow electric guitar hanging from his neck.

This was the only recurring sketch without Bynes' appearance (she introduces Kyle off-screen), and the only character from any skit to appear on All That.